• William Antonelli edited the blog post Full Stop Therapy for Disaffected Teens in the group Group logo of The Contemporary PoemThe Contemporary Poem: 8 years, 10 months ago

    Why is everyone on this blog always starting their comments with “Hey [author of post],” or “Hi [author of post]!”??? It gives every comment such a stilted and formal vibe, like we’re baby boomers on Facebook replying to a Happy Birthday from our second cousins. Why do we do it? Because we wanna buffer our scathing comments with polite formalities? I suppose it’s easier to tell someone to piss off when you address them very kindly by their name first

    It’s always amazing how such small additions to a comment can add such an emotional impact. Anyone who texts or chats on the internet often can tell you what a misplaced full stop/period can do to the emotional tone of your message. Consider:

    “It’s fine”

    vs.

    “It’s fine.”

    Doesn’t that second example carry so much more passive-aggression?

    Chrissy Montelli once called the millennial penchant for removing punctuation in order to seem less intense a sign that we’re all “disaffected teens.”

    We talk about this all the time in poetry, don’t we? Maybe not about the emotional impact that punctuation carries, but its sonic and rhythmic impact. A poem in which every line ends in a full stop reads much differently than a poem in which there’s no punctuation—the full stop version will come off as slower, stiffer, less breezy. Emdashes carry a different length of pause than semi-colons and colons and commas, which carry a different length of pause than periods. The smallest additions to a poem can drastically alter the way we read it. English is scary, and we should ban it from our schools.

    …and that’s all I got. Did I tie my complaint about commenting into poetry well enough to get away with it?

     

    P.S.: If anyone comments on this with “Hi Will!”, we’re gonna fight in the parking dock behind Letch