Show Sidebar Log in
English @ SUNY Geneseo The SUNY Geneseo English Community
  • Home
  • Members
  • Groups
  • Site-Wide Activity
  • Read the Terms and Conditions
  • Set up 2FA

Group Admins

  • Profile picture of The Management

Group Mods

  • Profile picture of English Department
  • Profile picture of Ed Gillin

Film Talk

Public Group active 7 years, 3 months ago

We talk film. Creative Commons-licensed avatar courtesy of Mr. Wabu .

Mr. Smith Takes Washington by Storm

  • This topic has 0 replies, 1 voice, and was last updated 9 years, 7 months ago by Kylie Sitar.
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • February 2, 2017 at 1:52 pm #936
    Kylie Sitar
    Participant

    <span style=”font-weight: 400;”>First off, even though I am not one for politics and this will not be an overwhelming part of my post, I don’t think I could respond to this film without at least briefly addressing the parallels between the political situation in this movie and the political situation in the United States today. The appointment of Jeff Smith was described as “political surprise”, much like many individuals would modestly describe the election of Donald Trump as President of the United States. I also believe that it is a more than fair assertion to say that both men were relatively unequip to take on their rather important political positions; the commonality being a lack of political experience. However, aside from these two things, the Donald Trump and Jeff Smith are vastly different characters. An example that I refer to is, while somewhat reluctantly accepting his nomination, Mr. Smith states that he “will do nothing to disgrace the office of US senator” and he kept true to this sentiment throughout the film. Donald Trump on the other hand, well you can take your pick. I’m not looking to spark a political debate here, I am just offering a comparison and inviting other opinions. </span>

    <span style=”font-weight: 400;”>The thing that I mainly want to focus on in this post is the contrast between the way that children viewed Mr. Smith and the way that the adults in the film view him. For the majority of the film, the number of adults who were a fan of, or even approved of Mr. Smith were very slim. The seemingly widespread belief was that Mr. Smith was the wrong person for the job and that he would be unsuccessful in the position. The children on the other hand, specifically the Governor’s four young boys who first plead the case to appoint Mr. Smith as senator, believed in him right from the start. The Boy Rangers knew very early on that Mr. Smith was exactly the kind of hero that could go on to do important things in Washington. Children are generally characterized as naive and lacking in worldly knowledge, but is that really true? Children have a very keen eye, almost an instinct when it comes to assessing the character of an individual. One scene that stands out to me was when Mr. Smith was accused of profiting from his bill and all of the boys took off their Boy Ranger pins and threw them in the garbage. Upon a little bit of reflection, one of the boys reattached the pin to the back of his lapel and showed it to Mr. Smith. This acted as almost a symbol that despite what may be going on outside, the heart of a child is still always in the right place. </span>

    <span style=”font-weight: 400;”>Why is it that adults are so quick to judge others and come to hastily conclusions while children are able to look past exterior influences and see the inner being of a person? Why does it take most of the adults in the film the entire course of events portrayed to confirm what young boys were able to articulate from one of the earliest scenes? I have many ideas running through my head as to the answer to this question, but one that seems to fit the context of this story the best is the idea that adults have obligations and responsibilities that stem from personal experiences. Our experiences affect and jade us in a way that we are unable to recognize. At the conclusion of the film, Mr. Paine becomes overwhelmed and is forced to confirm everything that Mr. Smith has been saying during his filibuster; thus discrediting the statements in support of Mr. Taylor, whom tightly pulled on the strings of every career choice that Mr. Paine has and will ever make. The situation of Mr. Paine is an exaggerated portrayal of the position that many individuals find themselves in due to the pressures and demands of life itself. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Mr. Smith is acting for outside forces as well. He is acting for the young boys that he has become a role model for. Even if it is sublime, we all have some obligations that sway our outlook and more importantly our actions; given a particular situation that might be viewed as positive or negative.   </span>

  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Log In
Group logo of Film Talk
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Announcements
  • Docs
  • Members 90

Recent Blog Posts

  • Profile picture of Emily Ludwig

    Emily Ludwig wrote a new blog post Warmth and Quiet Contemplation in Leave No Trace in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 3 months ago

    The film Leave No Trace felt warm and inviting throughout, despite tackling difficult issues almost constantly, and taking place in a wet and cold environment. I believe this almost cozy atmosphere is due in part […]

  • Profile picture of Brianna Forgione

    Brianna Forgione wrote a new blog post Fragile but still Strong in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 4 months ago

    Leave No Trace is about the relationship between a girl and her father. It’s a patient movie and a thorough one. It takes its time unveiling the details of their relationship and their lives. The father, (Ben […]

  • Profile picture of Molley Gross

    Molley Gross wrote a new blog post Ringing In Your Ears: The Relevance of “Children of Men” Today in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 4 months ago

    Alfonso Cuaron’s “Children of Men” opens on news reports of the chaos that has consumed the world in 2027. We soon discover humanity is suffering from an infertility crisis and that the U.K. is seemingly the only […]

  • Profile picture of Una McGowan

    Una McGowan wrote a new blog post Plot Armor in The Thing (1982) in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 4 months ago

    The concept of Plot Armor has existed forever and is something that any audience understands even if they don’t know that it has a name. In any given book, movie, tv show, or other form of story, the hero is g […]

  • Profile picture of Aileen Mack

    Aileen Mack wrote a new blog post Setting the Tone in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    I think because  I had already seen “Wind River” before we watched it in class I was able to appreciate the way director Taylor Sheridan was able to use the harsh Wyoming landscape to create the overwhelmingly […]

  • Profile picture of Mikhayla Graham

    Mikhayla Graham wrote a new blog post Could there possibly be two heros? in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    I went into this film never even having heard of it, and I finished the film thoroughly enjoying it. Cory Lambert (Jeremy Renner), is a wildlife conservation officer soon turned into a criminal investigator in a […]

  • Profile picture of Kelsey Kwandrans

    Kelsey Kwandrans wrote a new blog post Losing a Voice in The Razor’s Edge (1984) in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    While I was not necessarily hoping for a voice-over to represent the narrator, a possibility we discussed in class, I’ll admit my surprise at hearing that the whole character of the narrator was not included in t […]

  • Profile picture of Jessica Drechsler

    Jessica Drechsler wrote a new blog post The Inauthentic Portrayal of Larry in The Razors Edge in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    The 1984 film adaptation of the Somerset Maugham’s novel “The Razors Edge” starring Bill Murray was considered to be a massive failure by both critic and audience alike.  The budget for the film was 12 million […]

  • Profile picture of Aileen Mack

    Aileen Mack wrote a new blog post What Happened to Larry? in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    As we discussed in class, film adaptations are a tricky business. The Razor’s Edge proved to be an especially difficult adaptation as the novel’s characters are all filtered through the mind of the narrator, who […]

  • Profile picture of Patrick Alexander

    Patrick Alexander edited the blog post If a Tree Falls in the Woods… in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 6 months ago

    Labels like “hero” or “villain” are things that can only be given to someone by someone else, and are therefore based on outsider’s perceptions of those people. Novels like Deliverance or movies like Bad Day at B […]

More Blogs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of Paul Schacht
Profile picture of Gillian Paku
Profile picture of Beth McCoy
Profile picture of Jaidyn Vorpahl
Profile picture of Brenna Cumming
Profile picture of Kendra Brace
Profile picture of Anna Enright
Profile picture of Daphne Paul-LaRonca
Profile picture of Alex Campitiello
Profile picture of Marlea Petroziello
Profile picture of Brianna Tooke
Profile picture of Elizabeth Clodfelter
Profile picture of Skylar Riedell
Profile picture of Rebecca Fox
Profile picture of Avery Wolfe

Connect

@GeneseoEnglish

SUNY Geneseo English Department

english-at-geneseo-dot-edu

Terms and Conditions

Read our terms and conditions here.

Sitemap

  • Groups
  • Home Page
  • Members
  • Site-Wide Activity
  • Sites
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Two-factor authentication
Powered by Commons In A Box
Skip to toolbar
  • About WordPress
    • About WordPress
    • Get Involved
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Learn WordPress
    • Support
    • Feedback
  • Log In
  • Register