Show Sidebar Log in
English @ SUNY Geneseo The SUNY Geneseo English Community
  • Home
  • Members
  • Groups
  • Site-Wide Activity
  • Read the Terms and Conditions
  • Set up 2FA

Group Admins

  • Profile picture of The Management

Group Mods

  • Profile picture of English Department
  • Profile picture of Ed Gillin

Film Talk

Public Group active 7 years, 3 months ago

We talk film. Creative Commons-licensed avatar courtesy of Mr. Wabu .

Big Fish

  • This topic has 1 reply, 2 voices, and was last updated 12 years, 6 months ago by Jo-Ann Wong.
Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • February 15, 2014 at 6:23 am #238
    Courtney Bial
    Participant

    In Big Fish, there are many ways in which Edward Blooms story represents Campbell’s idea of the hero’s journey. Edwards’s character is told through story telling and so we mostly see his view of himself. The only other narrations in the film are his son at the beginning of the film and through Jenny, the woman who lives in Spectre. The points of views are important because they help the audience to see two different sides to one man. His sons perspective which is that his father makes up stories to make himself sound more interesting and from Jenny who sees all the good that he has done in his life, such as fixing up her house. Through Edwards’s flashbacks, the audience sees his journey as the hero in Big Fish.

     

    Edwards journey starts in his hometown of Ashton. He receives the call to adventure from within himself. He thinks that he has outgrown the tiny town and is destined for bigger and better things. There is two supernatural aids that exist in the film, the first of these being the witch, who helps Edward to see how he will die. This helps in become fearless in his journey, knowing that even as he comes across troubles he will have the will to get through them. This is seen both in the scene with the tree and also when he is an older man and he is saying that he knows he wont die where he is not. The second of the supernatural aids is Karl, the misunderstood giant. Karl help Edward in providing him the strength and the opportunity to finally leave his little town of Ashton. The crossing of the first threshold is seen during the parade scene, This is when Edward finally leaves home and sets out on his journey with Karl.

     

    The next step in Campbell’s depiction of the hero’s journey is Initiation. Perhaps the most important of these aspects of the journey is the road of trials. These are seen in all of the flashback and the stories that Edward tells. From the story about Spectre, escaping the forest, getting Sandra to marry him even when she was already engaged to another man, going into and coming home from the war in Korea, robing banks, saving Spectre and rebuilding Jenny’s house, Edward embarks on trials like none other, all teaching him a different lesson. Throughout all of these trials Edward has always remained himself up until his final days.

     

    The final stage in the hero’s journey according to Campbell is the return. One can argue that Edward never really return because he is always telling the stories of his journeys. He comes to life through his story telling and through them he will always live on. This is representative of the magic flight, Edwards, and the audiences, journey between his past and his present. The most powerful part of this movie is when Will takes on his father role, telling the stories of his life. This is the stage of being rescues from without. Edwards finally crosses the return threshold when his story telling passes on to future generations. Finally Edward has the freedom to live, or in this instance, to die. He knows that he will live forever through his stories. Thus he rounds out his journey as the hero in the eyes of Joseph Campbell.

    February 18, 2014 at 4:55 am #242
    Jo-Ann Wong
    Participant

    While I agree with your interpretation of the relation between Campbell’s hero and Edward Bloom, I think Will Bloom’s story can also be deconstructed in this manner. For instance, according to Campbell, there is a distaste for the father by the son due to the father’s ability to attract the mother’s attention away from the son. Similarly,in the movie, Edward draws the attention away from his son during his wedding party. Thus, Will shows antagonism towards his father. His call to “adventure,” however, is induced by learning his father is sick. While there, he gains help in understanding his father from his wife, who is the “Goddess” in Campbell’s text. His tests include accepting his father and his eventual reconciliation with his father is indicative of Will completing his spiritual journey and his “atonement with the father.” Finally understanding his father, he brings this knowledge back into his present life, which is seen when he tells Ed’s stories to his son, and is represented as the elixir in Campbell’s text.

  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • The topic ‘Big Fish’ is closed to new replies.
Group logo of Film Talk
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Announcements
  • Docs
  • Members 90

Recent Blog Posts

  • Profile picture of Emily Ludwig

    Emily Ludwig wrote a new blog post Warmth and Quiet Contemplation in Leave No Trace in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 3 months ago

    The film Leave No Trace felt warm and inviting throughout, despite tackling difficult issues almost constantly, and taking place in a wet and cold environment. I believe this almost cozy atmosphere is due in part […]

  • Profile picture of Brianna Forgione

    Brianna Forgione wrote a new blog post Fragile but still Strong in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 4 months ago

    Leave No Trace is about the relationship between a girl and her father. It’s a patient movie and a thorough one. It takes its time unveiling the details of their relationship and their lives. The father, (Ben […]

  • Profile picture of Molley Gross

    Molley Gross wrote a new blog post Ringing In Your Ears: The Relevance of “Children of Men” Today in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 4 months ago

    Alfonso Cuaron’s “Children of Men” opens on news reports of the chaos that has consumed the world in 2027. We soon discover humanity is suffering from an infertility crisis and that the U.K. is seemingly the only […]

  • Profile picture of Una McGowan

    Una McGowan wrote a new blog post Plot Armor in The Thing (1982) in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 4 months ago

    The concept of Plot Armor has existed forever and is something that any audience understands even if they don’t know that it has a name. In any given book, movie, tv show, or other form of story, the hero is g […]

  • Profile picture of Aileen Mack

    Aileen Mack wrote a new blog post Setting the Tone in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    I think because  I had already seen “Wind River” before we watched it in class I was able to appreciate the way director Taylor Sheridan was able to use the harsh Wyoming landscape to create the overwhelmingly […]

  • Profile picture of Mikhayla Graham

    Mikhayla Graham wrote a new blog post Could there possibly be two heros? in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    I went into this film never even having heard of it, and I finished the film thoroughly enjoying it. Cory Lambert (Jeremy Renner), is a wildlife conservation officer soon turned into a criminal investigator in a […]

  • Profile picture of Kelsey Kwandrans

    Kelsey Kwandrans wrote a new blog post Losing a Voice in The Razor’s Edge (1984) in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    While I was not necessarily hoping for a voice-over to represent the narrator, a possibility we discussed in class, I’ll admit my surprise at hearing that the whole character of the narrator was not included in t […]

  • Profile picture of Jessica Drechsler

    Jessica Drechsler wrote a new blog post The Inauthentic Portrayal of Larry in The Razors Edge in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    The 1984 film adaptation of the Somerset Maugham’s novel “The Razors Edge” starring Bill Murray was considered to be a massive failure by both critic and audience alike.  The budget for the film was 12 million […]

  • Profile picture of Aileen Mack

    Aileen Mack wrote a new blog post What Happened to Larry? in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 5 months ago

    As we discussed in class, film adaptations are a tricky business. The Razor’s Edge proved to be an especially difficult adaptation as the novel’s characters are all filtered through the mind of the narrator, who […]

  • Profile picture of Patrick Alexander

    Patrick Alexander edited the blog post If a Tree Falls in the Woods… in the group Group logo of Film TalkFilm Talk: 7 years, 6 months ago

    Labels like “hero” or “villain” are things that can only be given to someone by someone else, and are therefore based on outsider’s perceptions of those people. Novels like Deliverance or movies like Bad Day at B […]

More Blogs

Recently Active Members

Profile picture of Paul Schacht
Profile picture of Gillian Paku
Profile picture of Beth McCoy
Profile picture of Jaidyn Vorpahl
Profile picture of Brenna Cumming
Profile picture of Kendra Brace
Profile picture of Anna Enright
Profile picture of Daphne Paul-LaRonca
Profile picture of Alex Campitiello
Profile picture of Marlea Petroziello
Profile picture of Brianna Tooke
Profile picture of Elizabeth Clodfelter
Profile picture of Skylar Riedell
Profile picture of Rebecca Fox
Profile picture of Avery Wolfe

Connect

@GeneseoEnglish

SUNY Geneseo English Department

english-at-geneseo-dot-edu

Terms and Conditions

Read our terms and conditions here.

Sitemap

  • Groups
  • Home Page
  • Members
  • Site-Wide Activity
  • Sites
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Two-factor authentication
Powered by Commons In A Box
Skip to toolbar
  • About WordPress
    • About WordPress
    • Get Involved
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Learn WordPress
    • Support
    • Feedback
  • Log In
  • Register